Named-panel totals and the underlying booklet are not independently verified. No recorded dose or controlled comparison establishes a dilution effect; known-brand tasting is not a blind accuracy test.
The Glenmorangie example contrasts descriptive impressions and discusses disagreement between cited expert panels, followed by observation after adding water.
Supplied PDF 5
Supplied PDF 3
Aroma description and first example
Checked against all supplied text; recording and exact speech unverified. Verified means faithful representation of the partial transcript only.
No access / Systematic Whisky Appreciation — supplied partial transcript — source analysis
Evidence
The Glenmorangie example contrasts descriptive impressions and discusses disagreement between cited expert panels, followed by observation after adding water.
Location and context
Supplied PDF 3–5. Aroma description and first example. Partial machine transcript, not audio-verified speech.
Annotation
Named-panel totals and the underlying booklet are not independently verified. No recorded dose or controlled comparison establishes a dilution effect; known-brand tasting is not a blind accuracy test.
Citation MacLean — Aroma description and first example.