Tennessee upheld Lem Motlow’s conviction for post-ban whiskey production in 1911
Tennessee upheld Lem Motlow’s conviction for post-ban whiskey production in 1911

Tennessee upheld Lem Motlow’s conviction for post-ban whiskey production in 1911

Citation Notes

Citation Readiness
Ready
Claim ID
230
Claim Status
Used in Draft
Claim Text

The agreed facts in Motlow v. State state that Lem Motlow, proprietor of the Jack Daniel’s distillery in Moore County, manufactured 375 gallons of 100-proof whiskey for sale on May 25, 1911; the Tennessee Supreme Court affirmed his conviction under the 1909 manufacture-prohibition act.

Claim Type
Factual
Confidence
High
Counterevidence Excerpts
Counterevidence Notes

Counterevidence Sources
Drafts
Evidence Strength
Strong
Fact Check Notes

Verified against the complete Motlow opinion transcript on 2026-09-01.

Fact Check Status
Verified
Originating Working Notes
Qualifications

The agreed facts say the whiskey was not intended for beverage sale within Tennessee. The case supports enforcement against production for sale but does not by itself establish the later movement, ownership, or survival of every Jack Daniel’s asset or brand right.

Reasoning

The opinion records the agreed facts, conviction and sentence, and final affirmance. These elements document company-specific enforcement after the statutory effective date.

Review Notes

Publication-safe for the stated production, prosecution, and affirmance.

Sections
Supporting Sources
No access
Supporting Zettels
Themes