Abbott explicitly includes McGirr in the bibliography

Annotation

Challenges Claims

Citations

Abbott — Abbott explicitly includes McGirr in the bibliography — PDF 361–361

Context

Compare McGirr’s existing Literature Notes

Excerpt ID

3457

Excerpt Text

Abbott lists Lisa McGirr’s The War on Alcohol in the bibliography. This establishes a bibliographic connection, not dependence for every claim; shared conclusions require a claim-level source check before being counted as independent confirmation.

Literature Notes

The Ghosts of Eden Park — Narrative reconstruction, testimony, and scale claims

Locator End

361

Locator Start

361

Locator Type

Page

Originating Working Notes

Page (text)

Source

No access

Source Section

Supports Claims

Tags

Verification Notes

Checked against the supplied PDF as a faithful paraphrase; not independent validation of underlying historical claims.

Verification Status

Verified

Paraphrase

Abbott lists Lisa McGirr’s The War on Alcohol in the bibliography. This establishes a bibliographic connection, not dependence for every claim; shared conclusions require a claim-level source check before being counted as independent confirmation.

Locator

Physical PDF 361–361. Compare McGirr’s existing Literature Notes.

Evidence boundary

Source representation checked; underlying primary documents not independently inspected.