Carnegie encourages specific recognition and dignified correction, yet some stories endorse deception. The Lincoln letter is misdated; the supplied PDF has no promised index.
411
1
Whole-copy critical review; especially204–206,325–328,354–362,383–385
Verified as source representation, not universal empirical effect. All411sheets read. LOC letter dates January26,1863, unlike sheet325. Title/copyright and six relevant visual/layout sheets inspected. Printed-edition completeness not verified.
Evidence Map
204–206 welcomes disagreement;210 invites fact checking;290 reports public correction;354–355 repeats flawed market test;361–362 praises observable work;375–377 combines practice, feedback and encouragement. These passages support a proposed humane correction process, not a guaranteed learning effect.
Contradictions:197/299explicit deception;302shame;383threat of burning children. Exclude these from Academy practice.
LOC Hooker letter January26,1863 corrects suppliedsheet325'sApril26. See linked Literature Note for additional checks and exact limits. Copyright5 promises index; none in supplied411sheets. Full supplied-copy review completed, with that limitation.