Complete Guide 2022 — Repeated tasting descriptions under different bottles

Exclude affected descriptions from bottle-specific factual or sensory evidence until independently corroborated. Repetition cannot be counted as independent support. This audit cannot determine whether the error originated in publisher content or this supplied conversion.

These are different labeled releases. The locator range is a container; only the explicitly enumerated pages form this comparison. Earlier visual checks confirmed the repeated descriptions are in the rendered source, not just extraction artifacts.

In the supplied edition, Speyburn10/15 descriptions and scores recur under Talisker25/PortRuighe (PDF729–730 and760–761, with minor punctuation variation). Tomintoul25 text recurs under TullibardineSovereign with a different score (803/815). SecretIslay text and score recur under TheGauldrons (834/850).

850

729

Noncontiguous comparison: PDF729–730/760–761;803/815;834/850

All eight listed pages freshly reread; rendered pages760–761 and815 previously enlarged and inspected. Verified is internal textual comparison, not identification of which bottle the original description belongs to.