Valuable as triangulated sensory evidence when paired with dated labels and production records; bottle condition and reviewer subjectivity limit certainty. The antique tasting is observational and confounds bottle history, maturation, proof, recipe and storage. Entry-proof/lignin explanations are attributed hypotheses, not isolated experimental causes.
These are sensory observations from surviving bottles, not controlled reconstructions of historical production.
Cowdery records his impressions of antique Mammoth Cave and Old Fitzgerald alongside modern Weller at a 1996 tasting and discusses possible production explanations. The comparison preserves attributed observations but does not isolate entry proof, wood, recipe, age or bottle history.
Reviews — “Two Antiques and One Modern Bourbon from United Distillers”
Reviews — “Two Antiques and One Modern Bourbon from United Distillers”
Verified against extracted page text and the rendered PDF on 2026-08-27. Every rendered sheet was visually inspected; exact normalized-text comparison established that PDF sheets 140–275 duplicate sheets 4–139 and sheets 387–399 duplicate sheet 386. This record cites the first or unique occurrence; the split locator at pp. 137–139 and 276–280 is explicitly noted where applicable. Reader crosswalk checked 2026-09-16 against the supplied ebook headings and cited passage: Reviews — “Two Antiques and One Modern Bourbon from United Distillers”. Original internal coordinates: PDF p. 314; PDF p. 318. PDF positions and legacy Page are internal provenance, not print pagination; any earlier PDF-only citation policy is superseded. September 29 fresh audit: all unique text, bibliography and complete index read;399sheets visually surveyed and8details enlarged. Correct duplicate map:140–178=4–42;179=49;180–185=43–48;186–275=50–139. Final387–399 repeat final index content with OCR/navigation differences, not all exact normalized-text matches. PDF sheet coordinates are not print pages. Qualification: The antique tasting is observational and confounds bottle history, maturation, proof, recipe and storage. Entry-proof/lignin explanations are attributed hypotheses, not isolated experimental causes.
Capture evidence faithfully. Select one Source, record a usable locator, and preserve enough surrounding context to prevent misquotation.
Evidence
The verified paraphrase is stored in Excerpt Text. Excerpt Type distinguishes the paraphrase from direct quotation.
Location and context
Reader locator: Reviews — “Two Antiques and One Modern Bourbon from United Distillers”
Locator Type, Locator Start, Locator End, and Source Section recover the passage. Context records the surrounding argument.
Annotation
Annotation states the evidence's research use. Approved Tags, the canonical Source, the full-source Literature Note, and applicable Claims provide retrieval and traceability.