Practitioner guidance from 2014, not a controlled sensory experiment. Academy exercises should test variables explicitly rather than presenting preferences as universal laws.
Directly useful for a cocktails lesson on how preparation decisions change balance, texture, temperature, aroma, and the drink's evolution in the glass.
Simonson's preparation guidance treats ice form, dilution, the choice between sugar and syrup, bitter selection, expressed citrus oils, and stirring time as interacting parts of an Old-Fashioned rather than incidental finishing details.
Displayed book page 75; supplied PDF sheet 78
Displayed book page 70; supplied PDF sheet 72
Equipment, Ingredients, Sweeteners, Basic Syrups, Bitters, Garnishes, and Stirring
Paraphrase and locator checked against the supplied OCR text and rendered PDF. Verified means faithful source capture, not empirical validation.
No access → 
Evidence
Simonson’s preparation guidance treats ice form, dilution, the choice between sugar and syrup, bitter selection, expressed citrus oils, and stirring time as interacting parts of an Old-Fashioned rather than incidental finishing details.
Location and context
Displayed book pages 70–75; supplied PDF sheets 72–78.
Use note
Strong lesson-design material for controlled comparisons of texture, temperature, aroma, sweetness and dilution.
Qualification
Practitioner guidance from 2014, not controlled sensory evidence. Academy exercises should test one variable at a time and record observation separately from preference.