Annotation
Challenges Claims
Citations
Context
Excerpt ID
3652
Excerpt Text
The editorial's approximately 37000-adult wine/diabetes claim cites reference 25, but that entry is Foster-Powell et al.'s International table of glycemic index and glycemic load values: 2002, not the identified prospective alcohol cohort.
Locator End
3
Locator Start
2
Locator Type
Page
Originating Working Notes
Page (text)
Source
No access
Source Section
Supports Claims
Tags
Verification Notes
Claim on p.2 and reference25 on p.3 read; bibliography identity checked against PubMed12081815. Verification concerns the mismatch, not a health-benefit claim.
Verification Status
Verified
Citation audit
Compare the final paragraph of “Effects on Overall Health,” supplied p.2, with reference 25 on p.3. Reference identity. No health-benefit conclusion is supported by that citation. Miguez — Beverage-specific research and unsupported health inferences contains the complete critical review.