Original concise paraphrase. Use with the linked literature note's limitations and synthesis.
Contributor's argument in a 2010 edited philosophical anthology.
Features associated with Islay can be expressive without forming a necessary-and-sufficient test of geographic identity.
296
293
Chapter 18: Peat and Seaweed: The Expressive Character of Islay Whiskies (Kevin W. Sweeney)
Paraphrase checked against local PDF text; printed pp. 293–296 correspond to PDF pp. 313–316. Verification concerns faithful source representation, not external proof of the argument.
Paraphrase
Features associated with Islay can be expressive without forming a necessary-and-sufficient test of geographic identity.
Locator
Kevin W. Sweeney, “Peat and Seaweed: The Expressive Character of Islay Whiskies,” chapter 18, printed pp. 293–296 (PDF pp. 313–316).
Interpretation boundary
Source fidelity is verified; the philosophical argument or personal example is not thereby established as an empirical finding.