Evidence Record | Conflict Notes | Evidence Areas | Access Date | Review Status | Evidence Summary | Reliability | Publication Date | Disposition | Source Class | Source URL | Created | Page Title | Whiskey Profile | Evidence ID | Flavor Observations | Publisher |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Do not automatically transfer five years or the final 5% wheat to the unnumbered historical expression described in DeVito. Distillation origin and current availability remain unverified. | IdentityProofAgeMash BillAromaPalateFinish | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Review describes a five-year John David Albert Taos Lightning rye at 45% ABV, attributed recipe 95% rye/5% wheat, bottled in New Mexico, with a separate sensory review. | Secondary | Mixed | Independent Publication | Oct 7, 2026 10:55 PM | 3974 | Distiller / Amanda Schuster | ||||||
Long description calls it straight bourbon despite label wording with natural flavors. Keep exact wording and unresolved legal category; catalog scope can remain American Whiskey. Trade name does not prove the physical distillery. | IdentityClassificationProofAgeImage | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Front-label asset visually inspected: Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey With Natural Flavors, 40% ABV/80 proof. Catalog text supplies 36-month maturation and Kentucky distillation, maturation and bottling. | Primary | Mixed | Producer / Brand | Oct 7, 2026 10:54 PM | 3973 | Heaven Hill | ||||||
This evidence check does not constitute full profile verification or a fresh retail-stock check. | IdentityClassificationProofAgeMash Bill | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Producer specification review, October 7, 2026: Heaven Hill confirms four years, 100 proof and bottled-in-bond straight rye. The producer tasting sheet supplies 51% rye; the full 51/39/10 formula remains a reported secondary-source figure. Library review found conflicting rye-recipe claims in DeVito; those are not used to overwrite the producer disclosure. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Oct 7, 2026 10:53 PM | 3967 | |||||||
This evidence check does not constitute full profile verification or a fresh retail-stock check. | IdentityClassificationProofAgeMash Bill | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Producer specification review, October 7, 2026: current Baker’s product page confirms Kentucky straight bourbon, single barrel, 107 proof and a seven-year minimum. Exact age belongs to the individual barrel; the recorded full mash bill remains explicitly attributed to secondary reporting. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Oct 7, 2026 10:53 PM | 3970 | |||||||
This evidence check does not constitute full profile verification or a fresh retail-stock check. | IdentityClassificationProofAgeMash Bill | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Producer specification review, October 7, 2026: Bowman Brothers Small Batch is 90 proof/45% ABV, with corn, rye and malted barley and triple distillation described. This does not identify an upstream supplier or establish a current age statement. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Oct 7, 2026 10:53 PM | 3969 | |||||||
This evidence check does not constitute full profile verification or a fresh retail-stock check. | IdentityClassificationProofAgeMash Bill | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Producer specification review, October 7, 2026: Lux Row distinguishes Reserve’s corn/rye/barley recipe from wheated 1843. Its extra-aged description is not a numeric age statement. This source does not identify the distilling facility for the reviewed release. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Oct 7, 2026 10:53 PM | 3972 | |||||||
This evidence check does not constitute full profile verification or a fresh retail-stock check. | IdentityClassificationProofAgeMash Bill | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Producer specification review, October 7, 2026: Luxco’s September 24, 2018 launch confirms seven years and 117 proof. Its $39.99 MSRP is historical. Breaking Bourbon reports 78% corn/12% malted barley/10% rye; conflicting secondary recipes exist, and the producer launch does not supply percentages. No distilling facility or current availability is inferred. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Oct 7, 2026 10:53 PM | 3971 | |||||||
This evidence check does not constitute full profile verification or a fresh retail-stock check. | IdentityClassificationProofAgeMash Bill | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Producer specification review, October 7, 2026: product listing identifies Virginia straight bourbon, single barrel and 100 proof. No current numeric age statement or upstream distilling facility is established by this check. Historical reviews remain dated evidence. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Oct 7, 2026 10:53 PM | 3968 | |||||||
Separate Governor’s Reserve entry is four years old; do not transfer its age. Distillation origin and current availability unresolved. Duplicated tasting wording is not independent sensory corroboration. | IdentityClassificationProofMash BillRelease Details | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Original scanned page visually inspected. John David Albert’s Taos Lightning Single Barrel Straight Rye is identified at 90 proof, 95% rye, new charred American oak, with chill filtration and individually numbered/dated bottles. | Secondary | Supports | Knowledge Library | Oct 7, 2026 10:46 PM | The Spirit of Rye, printed page 448 / supplied PDF sheet 424 | 3966 | Carlo DeVito, The Spirit of Rye (2021) | |||||
Current store price $73 versus older sheet $69.99. No age or exact federal category verified. Sensory descriptions are producer-only; used casks do not prove secondary finishing. | IdentityProofMash BillRelease DetailsAromaPalateFinishImage | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Producer identifies 100% malted Conlon barley, Michigan peat, double-pot distillation, second-use bourbon/rye cask maturation at 110 entry proof and 100-proof bottling. Current official store cross-checked; photo inspected. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Oct 7, 2026 10:46 PM | Northern Single Malt — 2024 sales sheet | 3965 | Mammoth Distilling | |||||
Do not transfer specifications from the separate Signature Whiskey product or infer Nebraska distillation. | IdentityClassificationProofMash BillPriceImage | October 7, 2026 | Verified | Official product listing and bottle photograph inspected October 7, 2026. Bourbon, 90 proof/45% ABV, 750 mL, 21% rye, price $59.95. Remaining grain percentages, age and distilling origin not supplied. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Oct 7, 2026 10:46 PM | Soldier Valley Lee Greenwood Signature Bourbon | 3964 | Soldier Valley Spirits | |||||
Publication date comes from the public product .js endpoint. Retailer text largely repeats producer material and supplies no independent tasting. Image rights remain with the original owner. | IdentityClassificationProofAgeAvailabilityPriceImage | October 5, 2026 | Proposed | October 5 check: preorder offered at $59.99, with seven years and 110.8 proof matching the announcement. Product JSON reports available=true and publication on October 2 at 14:52:50 EDT. Photograph shows a 750 mL Indiana straight bourbon bottle with 2026 on the label. Dispatch date is unconfirmed. | Primary | October 2, 2026 2:52 PM (GMT-4) | Supports | Retailer | Oct 5, 2026 9:55 AM | [Pre-Sale] Starlight Distillery Estate Collection Indiana Straight Bourbon Whiskey | 3962 | Seelbach's | ||||
Independent publisher, but this article's tasting material is producer-supplied. It does not provide a second independent sensory assessment. | IdentityRelease DetailsAvailability | October 5, 2026 | Proposed | Reports the October 3 distillery and online launch. Supports the release timeline; the article attributes sensory descriptions to the brand. | Secondary | October 2, 2026 | Supports | Independent Publication | Oct 5, 2026 9:55 AM | Starlight Distillery Releases 7-Year Cask Strength Estate Bourbon | 3963 | The Whiskey Wash | ||||
Press-release republication: do not count Whiskey Consensus as an independent sensory source. | IdentityProofAgeMash BillRelease DetailsPriceAromaPalateFinish | October 5, 2026 | Proposed | Producer press release announces the annual 2026 Estate Collection for October 3 at $59.99. Seven-year bourbon, 110.8 proof; sweet-mash fermentation and double pot distillation. All production occurs on the Huber estate, with 80% estate-grown grain. The remaining grain origin and recipe percentages are not specified. | Primary | October 1, 2026 | Supports | Producer / Brand | Oct 5, 2026 9:55 AM | Annual Release Crafted in Collaboration with the Estate Whiskey Alliance Celebrates Whiskey Rooted in PlaceStarlight, Indiana | 3961 | Producer-only concepts: aroma—oak, vanilla, baking spices, dried fruit and caramel; taste—plum, coconut and brown sugar; finish—persistent sweetness, spice, oak and warmth. These are promotional observations, not an independent tasting. | Starlight Distillery via Whiskey Consensus | |||
IdentityProofAgeRelease DetailsAvailabilityPriceAromaPalateFinishImage | September 28, 2026 | Proposed | Official producer-direct storefront showed the seven-year Batch 6 in stock at $79.99 and shipping to most U.S. states plus Washington, D.C. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 28, 2026 9:48 AM | O.H. Ingram Flagship Bourbon Batch 6 113.8 Proof | 3960 | Official notes support a dessert-forward profile of pastry, honey, vanilla, milk chocolate, coconut, caramel, graham, nougat, cream soda, cinnamon, cocoa, and sandalwood. | The Ingram Distillery | |||||
IdentityClassificationProofAgeRelease DetailsAvailabilityPriceAromaPalateFinishImage | September 28, 2026 | Proposed | Official producer storefront showed the 123-proof, six-year single barrel in stock at $90, with Colorado production details and multi-state shipping restrictions. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 28, 2026 9:48 AM | American Single Malt Whiskey, Cask Strength 6-Year Single Barrel | 3958 | Producer notes support floral and mint aromas with cardamom and allspice, followed by cherry, roasted grain, cocoa, baking spice, and a bright botanical finish. | Root Shoot Spirits | |||||
IdentityClassificationProofAgeRelease DetailsAvailabilityPriceAromaPalateFinishImage | September 28, 2026 | Proposed | Official producer storefront showed the 100-proof, six-year whiskey in stock at $84.99, with Colorado production details and multi-state shipping restrictions. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 28, 2026 9:48 AM | American Single Malt Whiskey, 6-Year Small Batch Bottled-in-Bond | 3957 | Producer notes support a malt-led, nutty and sweet profile with leather, brown sugar, vanilla, caramel, dried cherry, spice, cocoa, eucalyptus, and camphor. | Root Shoot Spirits | |||||
IdentityClassificationProofAgeMash BillRelease DetailsAvailabilityPriceAromaPalateFinish | September 28, 2026 | Proposed | Dated release report confirms the annual Batch 6 as a seven-year, 113.8-proof wheated Kentucky straight bourbon assembled from 25 barrels and available in select markets and direct to consumer. | Strong Secondary | September 22, 2026 | Supports | Independent Publication | Sep 28, 2026 9:48 AM | Ingram Flagship Batch Six Bourbon Lands for Heritage Month | 3959 | Reported producer notes point to pastry, honey, vanilla, chocolate, coconut, caramel, graham, nougat, cream soda, cinnamon, cocoa, and dry sandalwood. | The Whiskey Wash | ||||
IdentityClassificationProofAgeMash BillRelease DetailsAvailabilityPriceAromaPalateFinish | September 28, 2026 | Proposed | Producer-issued release confirms two first-ever six-year Root Shoot American single malts, their proofs, maturation details, limited online quantities, suggested prices, and immediate availability. | Primary | September 22, 2026 | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 28, 2026 9:48 AM | Root Shoot Spirits Releases Two Limited-Edition 6-Year American Single Malt Whiskies Online Nationwide | 3956 | The bottled-in-bond release centers malt, brown sugar, leather, caramel, cherry, spice, cocoa, and cooling herbal notes. The single-barrel release emphasizes flowers, mint, cardamom, dark cherry, toasted grain, cocoa, spice, and botanicals. | Root Shoot Spirits via BevNET | ||||
IdentityProofAromaPalateFinish | September 25, 2026 | Proposed | Second tasting from a sample supplied by first reviewer. Not a separate batch. | Secondary | Supports | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 1:37 PM | Review 523 — Madeira 2020 | 3955 | Bailzay / r/bourbon | ||||||
IdentityProofAromaPalateFinish | September 25, 2026 | Proposed | Owner photograph, strength, release context and sensory notes. | Secondary | Supports | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 1:37 PM | Review 216 — Madeira 2020 | 3954 | washeewashee / r/bourbon | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease Details | September 25, 2026 | Proposed | Confirms 92 proof, five-barrel release and bourbon older than five years before finishing. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 1:34 PM | 2025 Harvest Release announcement | 3952 | Woodinville Whiskey Co. | ||||||
ImageProofPalateAromaFinish | September 25, 2026 | Proposed | Bottle photograph confirms release and port-wine finish; tasting impressions are one review, not Academy evidence. | Secondary | Supports | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 1:34 PM | Review #252: Triple Barrel II 2025 | 3953 | washeewashee / r/bourbon | ||||||
PalateIdentity | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | A separate 2019 distillery visit describes Chocolate Malt with dark chocolate, vanilla and a faint smoky sweetness. This supports cocoa as a trial blending contribution. Batch is unidentified; smoke is a tasting impression, not evidence of a peated-cask finish. | Secondary | Supports | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 3:21 AM | Widow Jane Distillery Visit | 3951 | Whiskery Turnip | ||||||
PalateIdentity | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | An independent 2019 distillery visit also describes Wapsie Valley as light, sweet and notably citrus-led. The visitor does not identify a batch, so this supports the expression-level citrus hypothesis rather than every historical bottle. | Secondary | Supports | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 3:21 AM | Widow Jane Distillery Visit | 3950 | Whiskery Turnip | ||||||
IdentityProofImageAge | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | Expression photograph and 91 proof. NAS metadata differs from the older Batch 2 review. | Strong Secondary | Mixed | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 3:18 AM | Widow Jane Chocolate Malt Bourbon | 3949 | The Daily Pour | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofAromaPalateFinish | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | Batch-specific identity, age and sensory evidence; detailed properties preserve attribution. | Strong Secondary | Supports | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 3:18 AM | Widow Jane Chocolate Malt Whiskey Review | 3948 | The Whiskey Reviewer | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofAromaPalateFinishRelease Details | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | 5years; 122.8proof;95%rye5%maltedbarley;Bardstown Bourbon Company. r/bourbon2023 selection. Selector identifies Bardstown Bourbon Company for distillation and aging,95%rye5%maltedbarley; Bourbonary quotes Bardstown Kentucky bottling label. Precise bottling site unverified. Selector reports ginger, honey, rye bread, pepper, fruit and tobacco. | Secondary | Supports | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 3:12 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 061 | 3946 | t8ke — barrel selector | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofAromaPalateFinishRelease Details | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | 5years; 123.2proof;95%rye5%maltedbarley;Bardstown Bourbon Company. PursuitPalooza2023 selection. Retailer identifies Bardstown Bourbon Company,95/5recipe and Kelvin toasted,char3 barrel. Wine/sherry-like notes are sensory descriptions, not evidence of sherry finishing. Nose:Toasted oak, wine-like fruit, ginger and anise. Palate:Brown sugar, honey, dry wine-like notes and grape candy. Finish:Ginger candy and faint mint. | Secondary | Supports | Retailer | Sep 25, 2026 3:12 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 058 | 3945 | Seelbach's | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofAromaPalateFinishRelease Details | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | 5years;61.4%ABV;Bardstown distillation and bottling label quoted. Firsthand notes emphasize chocolate, caramel, nougat, pepper, honey, nuts and citrus. | Secondary | Supports | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 3:12 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 061 | 3947 | Bourbonary | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | July 2022; 6 years; 121.5 proof; 154 bottles. Producer-confirmed Woodinville bourbon. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:09 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 054 | 3939 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | May producer archive / June selector release 2023; 6 years; 119.3 proof; 191 bottles. Breaking Bourbon selection:SBC78. Selector gives6years5months and June2023 distribution versus producer May2023 archive date; both retained. | Primary | Mixed | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:09 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 056 | 3941 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | July 2022; 6 years; 121.2 proof; 173 bottles. 309 Bourbon Society private selection. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:09 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 053 | 3938 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
AgeProofAromaPalateFinishRelease Details | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | 78% corn, 10% rye, 12% malted barley — selector disclosure. Nose: Caramel, currant, cinnamon candy, leather and fig. Palate: Baking spice, peach bread, cinnamon, charred oak and green pepper. Finish: White pepper, vanilla, oak, chocolate and clove. Breaking Bourbon selection:SBC78. Selector gives6years5months and June2023 distribution versus producer May2023 archive date; both retained. | Secondary | Mixed | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 3:09 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 056 | 3942 | Breaking Bourbon — barrel selector | ||||||
AgeProofAromaPalateFinishRelease Details | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | 100% rye — retailer specification. Nose: Not separately described. Palate: Retailer describes apple pastry, cider, citrus, cedar, cinnamon and floral notes. Finish: Retailer describes peach tea. Retailer specifies5years7months11days,100%rye and Speyside char3 barrel. Producer describes Honeycrisp apple. Retailer page currently marked out of stock79.99USD. | Secondary | Supports | Retailer | Sep 25, 2026 3:09 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 057 | 3944 | Seelbach's | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | July 2022; 6 years; 120.7 proof; 180 bottles. Penny & Sparrow selection. No specific sensory components disclosed. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:09 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 051 | 3936 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | July 2022; 6 years; 117.7 proof; 173 bottles. Stanley Vault at The Stanley Hotel selection. Archive117.7proof conflicts with58.35%ABV (116.7proof); exact strength remains unresolved. | Primary | Mixed | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:09 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 052 | 3937 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | July 2022; 7 years; 103.1 proof; 150 bottles. J bar M Ranch, Montague County, Texas private barrel. Selection location is not distillation origin. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:09 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 055 | 3940 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | May 2023; 5 years; 115.8 proof; 177 bottles. Retailer specifies5years7months11days,100%rye and Speyside char3 barrel. Producer describes Honeycrisp apple. Retailer page currently marked out of stock79.99USD. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:09 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 057 | 3943 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
ProofPriceRelease Details | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | Historical listing confirms Episode050, proof100.8,79USD. Not current availability. | Secondary | Mixed | Retailer | Sep 25, 2026 3:06 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 050 | 3935 | Seelbach's | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | July 2022; 6 years; 114.1 proof; 195 bottles. Bourbon Pursuit Discord selection. Archived Seelbach's blog listed79USD; historical reference only. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:06 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 049 | 3932 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
ProofPriceRelease Details | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | Historical listing confirms Episode049, proof114.1,79USD. Not current availability. | Secondary | Supports | Retailer | Sep 25, 2026 3:06 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 049 | 3933 | Seelbach's | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | July 2022; 5 years; 102 proof; 180 bottles. Selected by r/bourbon; producer identifies Finger Lakes. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:06 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 048 | 3931 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | July 2022; 4 years; 100.8 proof; 191 bottles. Five-grain rye selected by Bourbon Pursuit Discord. Grain percentages and complete recipe undisclosed. Archive ABV40.4% conflicts with100.8proof (50.4%); explicit proof supported by Seelbach's historical listing. Archived retailer price79USD is not current. | Primary | Mixed | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:06 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 050 | 3934 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | July 2021; 5 years; 121.8 proof; 187 bottles. Producer identifies Woodinville Whiskey Co. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:04 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 043 | 3926 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
Release DetailsPrice | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | October18,2021 email:5years,120.7proof,180bottles,$65. Bottle count conflicts with producer179. Historical price only. | Secondary | Mixed | Retailer | Sep 25, 2026 3:04 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 046 | 3929 | Seelbach's via Milled | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | July 2022; 5 years; 102.4 proof; 130 bottles. Dallas Bourbon Club private selection. New York source distiller not named in this archive entry; Finger Lakes is not inferred. Producer stock image is low resolution. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:04 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 047 | 3930 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | November 2021; 5 years; 120 proof; 185 bottles. Private selection for Emma and Ben's wedding. | Primary | Supports | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:04 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 045 | 3927 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
IdentityAgeProofRelease DetailsImage | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | September 2021; 5 years; 120.7 proof; 179 bottles. Producer count179 conflicts with archived Seelbach's email count180. Producer count retained; total unresolved. October18,2021 email offered $65; historical price, not current stock. | Primary | Mixed | Producer / Brand | Sep 25, 2026 3:04 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 046 | 3928 | Pursuit Spirits | ||||||
AromaPalateFinish | September 24, 2026 | Proposed | Nose: Floral rye, charred oak, vanilla, chocolate, molasses, ripe fruit and earth. Palate: Chewy floral-fruity rye spice, oak and vanilla. Finish: Long, lingering floral, fruit and oak flavors with little perceived burn. Firsthand review; no Academy tasting. | Secondary | Supports | Independent Publication | Sep 25, 2026 3:01 AM | Pursuit Series Episode 041 | 3922 | ryanc919 / Distiller | ||||||