Retain as a secondary roadmap and identify claim-level checks. Invention, earliest located print attestation, recipe variation and popularization must be separate timeline event types. Do not equate a later book's publication date with a cocktail's invention.
The entire written source was reviewed. Comments, when present, are distinguished from the authored article.
Timeline headings:1806Whiskey Cocktail;1862Improved Whiskey Cocktail;1888Proulx/name;1934Burke fruit;1939Wisconsin;1990s/2000srevival;2007Oaxaca;2010ssmoke. Article attributes a earliest1862recipe and improved formula to Thomas without separating editions, and1888first naming to Proulx; these priority/edition claims need checking. Wisconsin narrative invokes1893Korbel, Prohibition andWWIIwhileheading1939may suggest false precision. Later sections nameEmployeesOnly/Pegu,PhilWard/Death&CoandDonLee/PDT;creationdates require primary corroboration. No exact quotations reused here.
Revival, Oaxaca and smoked sections
1806 and1862 sections
1806 and1862 sections; 1888 and1934 sections; 1939 Wisconsin section; Revival, Oaxaca and smoked sections
Source-faithful paraphrase only; not independent corroboration. Several first/earliest statements, Thomas edition attribution and regional origin lore are unverified. The broad bootleg-liquor masking explanation is not evidence that cocktails generally arose for that purpose. Modern recipe directions and garnish-fire wording are not adopted as technique instruction. Infographic and image remain unreviewed; Simonson book not newly processed from this article.
No access / Whiskey Excerpts Database (USWA)
Source-faithful paraphrase. Verified does not mean independently corroborated.
Evidence
Timeline headings:1806Whiskey Cocktail;1862Improved Whiskey Cocktail;1888Proulx/name;1934Burke fruit;1939Wisconsin;1990s/2000srevival;2007Oaxaca;2010ssmoke. Article attributes a earliest1862recipe and improved formula to Thomas without separating editions, and1888first naming to Proulx; these priority/edition claims need checking. Wisconsin narrative invokes1893Korbel, Prohibition andWWIIwhileheading1939may suggest false precision. Later sections nameEmployeesOnly/Pegu,PhilWard/Death&CoandDonLee/PDT;creationdates require primary corroboration. No exact quotations reused here.
Location and context
No access. 1806 and1862 sections; 1888 and1934 sections; 1939 Wisconsin section; Revival, Oaxaca and smoked sections.
Full written article reviewed; embedded evidence remains pending.
Annotation
Retain as a secondary roadmap and identify claim-level checks. Invention, earliest located print attestation, recipe variation and popularization must be separate timeline event types. Do not equate a later book's publication date with a cocktail's invention.
Several first/earliest statements, Thomas edition attribution and regional origin lore are unverified. The broad bootleg-liquor masking explanation is not evidence that cocktails generally arose for that purpose. Modern recipe directions and garnish-fire wording are not adopted as technique instruction. Infographic and image remain unreviewed; Simonson book not newly processed from this article.