Appendix XIV retracts earlier mechanism explanations. Appendix XI admits sparse sex-specific threshold data. Numerical model weights and bias anecdotes remain unvalidated.
Critical full-source reading of SRC-627. Captured PDF screens, not printed pages; qualified source evidence, not blanket factual endorsement.
Appendices cover stills, instruments, testing, biases, sex differences, physical models and corrections to the author's 2018 report.
PDF screen 625
PDF screen 589
Appendices VII–XIV
Verified against supplied source as a paraphrase and critical reading disposition; uncorroborated underlying claims explicitly not promoted.
Whiskey Excerpts Database (USWA)
Verified capture of an attributed source position, not independent endorsement of all underlying claims.
Evidence
Appendices cover stills, instruments, testing, biases, sex differences, physical models and corrections to the author's 2018 report.
Location and context
No access — Appendices VII–XIV, PDF screens 589–625. These are screen locators, not printed pages.
Annotation
Appendix XIV retracts earlier mechanism explanations. Appendix XI admits sparse sex-specific threshold data. Numerical model weights and bias anecdotes remain unvalidated.
Related analysis: Distilled Spirits Sensory Science — critical reading and application.
Verification checklist
September27 citation audit of AppendixXIV
Directly read and visually checked screens624–625. Two DOI references do not identify the stated papers:10.1016/j.foodres.2020.109412 is Nguyen et al. on palm-oil/milk-fat crystallization;10.1093/chemse/27.3.215 is Kinoshita et al. on mouse olfactory-pathway labeling. Dalton DOI25.6.733 unresolved in this check. The author's correction remains accurately captured, but these citations do not validate its replacement mechanism. Nguyen; Kinoshita. Full article audit: Nosing-vessel claims require independent sensory validation — Manska.