Reclassified as researcher synthesis. PDF163–169 discusses wood and storage effects but does not demonstrate adjunct/barrel inequivalence;177 actually asserts equivalence. Do not attribute our corrective distinction to Hyde as his demonstrated conclusion.
The pages cover wood format, contact, oxygen, storage, and time.
Researcher synthesis from Hyde's wood discussion: extraction, oxygen exposure, evaporation and time should be distinguished. Hyde himself asserts adjunct equivalence at PDF177; the claim that extraction does not reproduce full barrel maturation requires other technical evidence and is not his demonstrated conclusion.
PDF sheet 169
PDF sheet 163
Aging with Wood
Fresh complete supplied-copy audit: 382 sheets read, all surveyed and135 detailed visual pages inspected. Reclassified as researcher synthesis. PDF163–169 discusses wood and storage effects but does not demonstrate adjunct/barrel inequivalence;177 actually asserts equivalence. Do not attribute our corrective distinction to Hyde as his demonstrated conclusion.
Verified evidence record from Aaron Hyde's How to Distill.
Captured evidence
Researcher synthesis from Hyde's wood discussion: extraction, oxygen exposure, evaporation and time should be distinguished. Hyde himself asserts adjunct equivalence at PDF177; the claim that extraction does not reproduce full barrel maturation requires other technical evidence and is not his demonstrated conclusion.
Locator
- Local PDF: PDF sheets 163–169
- Source section: Aging with Wood
- Locator convention: PDF-sheet number, used because the 382-sheet fixed-layout file does not match the edition's 224-page bibliographic pagination
Context
The pages cover wood format, contact, oxygen, storage, and time.
Research annotation
Reclassified as researcher synthesis. PDF163–169 discusses wood and storage effects but does not demonstrate adjunct/barrel inequivalence;177 actually asserts equivalence. Do not attribute our corrective distinction to Hyde as his demonstrated conclusion.