Experienced tasters and an untrained comparison group evaluated selected wines under organic/conventional information conditions. Expectations and fault-related descriptors influenced interpretation and reported valuation in this study.
Source And Coverage
No access
Romano et al. (2020) — DOI
PDF sheets 1, 3–4 and 9–10; participant design and selected results.
Review completed October 24, 2026 using whole-file searchable extraction and targeted reading. “Complete” describes this scoped note, not an exhaustive audit. Page locators refer to the supplied PDF unless printed pages are specified.
Findings And Method
Experienced tasters and an untrained comparison group evaluated selected wines under organic/conventional information conditions. Expectations and fault-related descriptors influenced interpretation and reported valuation in this study.
Evidence Boundaries
Selected wines and unbalanced organic/conventional coverage do not establish a causal effect of farming method on faults. Fixed-session/context effects matter. The untrained comparison lacks a complete matched information contrast. Ratios of ordinal liking scores are not meaningful percentage gains in enjoyment; willingness-to-pay categories are hypothetical, not transactions.
Blending Lab Application — Researcher Synthesis
Use the paper to motivate separate blind and informed records and a discussion of expectation. Do not teach that organic wines inherently taste worse or that experts are immune to labels.
The practical recommendation is distinct from the authors' tested result. Established chemistry and measurement definitions can be taught directly; a particular whiskey's response, a consumer segment or a profitable offer still requires appropriate evidence.
Connected Research
- No access — compare method, population and outcome before combining evidence.
- No access — compare method, population and outcome before combining evidence.
Academy Use
The Short Version can teach the practical comparison; the Full Story should explain the mechanism, source method and limits. Use this note with No access and No access.
Pricing and membership remain proposals to test; this source does not validate a commercial offer.
Linked Analyses And Batch Register
Effects of Non-Sensory Cues on Perceived Quality: The Case of Low-Alcohol Wine — Evidence and Blending Lab Applications- The Influence of Selected Senses on Consumer Experience: A Brandy Case — Evidence and Blending Lab Applications
No access